Choosing the Best Cat Scratcher

As cat parents, we’ve probably all dealt with our cats scratching a surface that wasn’t intended for their lovely little claws. Your carpet, your sofa, maybe your cute kitten wallpaper. So, how can you discourage this behavior? One option is to ensure you choose the best type of scratcher for your cat.

Being a cat mom for over 14 years now, I’ve seen my fair share of scratching posts and scratchers. So, I’ll help you pick out one or two that might work well in your house.

But before we talk about choosing the best cat scratcher, let’s look at why cats scratch in the first place.

Disclosure: Some links below are affiliate links. This means that at no cost to you, I will earn an affiliate commission if you click the link and complete a purchase.

Why Do Cats Scratch?

Well, there are a few reasons that cats scratch. An obvious one is claw maintenance. When they scratch, the motion helps the cat shed that dead outer layer (known as the sheath) and expose a new, sharper claw beneath. When you trim your cat’s nails, you’re also helping remove the sheath.

Another reason cats scratch is to mark their territory. When a cat scratches, scent glands in its paws leave scent marks on the surface, letting another cat know they’ve claimed that territory.

Cats also scratch for stretching purposes. When a cat digs their claws into a scratcher, it helps them grab hold and do a deeper stretch, reaching all of its muscles and helping maintain flexibility. Stretching helps keep your cat’s body in good condition.

And finally, your cat may scratch for stress relief. If your cat has pent-up energy or frustration, scratching can help release this, making them feel more relaxed.

Great, now we know why cats need to scratch. So, how can we get them to scratch the correct object in your house? One way is by ensuring you have several cat scratchers or scratching posts available to them.

Choosing the Best Cat Scratcher

So many cat scratchers and scratching posts are on the market, and my cats have used several types. I recommend having more than one type of scratcher in your house, as different scratchers can serve different purposes. You’ll likely learn which one(s) your cat prefers by offering them options to choose from. You’ll also want to have the scratchers in multiple rooms or areas of the house. And the scratchers should be placed in easily accessible areas, not always tucked into the corner of a room, or else your cat might not use it.

Types of Cat Scratchers

Tall sisal scratching post

A taller option allows the cat to reach up and stretch down simultaneously, helping them achieve that deep stretch. When selecting the scratching post, you’ll want to ensure that the cat has enough room to reach above its head, allowing for a full stretch. Woodrow demonstrates this with the Art of Paws scratching post.

Also, check that it’s a heavy-duty scratching post. You want a solid base that won’t tip over when your cat uses it. Sophie tests the Hauspanther MaxScratch Oversized Cat Scratching Post.

Some scratching posts also have a big enough area or a perch on top so that it doubles as a place for your cat to survey their domain. Here, Sophie enjoys watching bird TV from the top of her scratching post.

Overall, I find that the tall sisal cat scratcher is the best scratching post for cats’ nails. Usually, I find an assortment of nail sheaths at the base of ours.

We received the Art of Paws scratcher for free years ago and wrote a full review about it. Unfortunately, it’s currently out of stock. We bought the MaxScratch Oversized Cat Scratching Post from Hauspanther. Unfortunately, it too is out of stock right now. But there are other tall sisal scratching post options on Amazon and elsewhere like this one.

Horizontal cat scratcher

If you’re out shopping in a big box store, they will likely have these horizontal cat scratchers in their pet section.

These types of scratchers are cheap, easy to move around, and most cats take to them. Some are also sold with catnip that you can sprinkle on to encourage your cat to use it. (Although some owners find this a deterrent to buying it if their cat doesn’t like catnip.) Some horizontal cat scratchers are sold with a base enclosure; then, you can replace the inserted cardboard scratcher section as needed.

Here is a refillable option on Amazon.

Vertical cardboard scratcher

If your cat is really into cardboard but scratching vertically, then this type might be a good fit. The ones we bought weren’t very tall, so they won’t replace a taller sisal scratching post. We had set our vertical cardboard scratcher outside of the litter area, and it was used like clockwork after the cats did their business.

Here’s the vertical cat scratcher the cats are currently using from Amazon.

Cardboard scratcher ramp

Talking about the litter area, we recently learned about a new scratcher ramp that is designed to help your cat go in and out of the litter box called Purrfectly Clean Paws from Simply Paws Design. The scratcher portion inside the ramp is meant to help capture litter. It’s great for a senior kitty or a cat with mobility issues. We were sent this for free to try out. The company did not ask for a review, but I’m including it since readers may be interested in it.

Here’s another scratcher ramp option that’s meant more for play. And it’s the perfect size for a kitten to peek in and out of. (We purchased this ramp when we had foster kittens.)

Check out the Kong Naturals Incline Cat Scratcher on Amazon.

Cardboard scratcher bed or lounger

Now, we’re getting into a bit more decorative scratchers that also serve as a place to lounge. We have had several scratcher beds and loungers over the years. They serve the purpose of allowing your cat to scratch while also offering a place to hang out. My cats love these types of scratchers.

I don’t recall where we bought the hexagon scratcher pictured above, but it’s double-sided and could be flipped over. I’m pretty sure we purchased the couch scratcher from TJ Maxx or HomeGoods. They always seem to have fun cardboard scratchers in their pet section, and they’re not too pricey.

Cardboard house scratcher

Many big box stores have these types of cat house scratchers. Is it just a gimmick to keep you buying one for every season? Probably. Do I do it? Yes. But in all honesty, they are pretty great. My cats love to hang out in these cat house scratchers. They offer a safe, enclosed space, and the cat can also scratch when they feel the urge. Oh, and they’re cute (the scratchers and the cats).

Both of these scratchers (spring and Christmas) are from Target.

Other fun scratchers

Cat scratchers are also made in unique shapes and designs. Some are cardboard, while others are pretty extravagant. I tend to stick to the “cheaper” cardboard designs since they’re easily replaced and not too hard on the pocketbook. We’ve bought many round scratchers that the cats love using as beds. There are also cute ones with fun-shaped openings. I believe both of these were from TJ Maxx or HomeGoods.

While this Catit scratcher is pretty cute, the cats don’t use it for scratching. My guess is because it’s not tall (to reach up to) and also not flat. So, maybe it’s too awkward to use for scratching. But they do sit on top of it and hang out inside of it.

Check out the Catit cat bench on Amazon.

Cat trees with built-in scratchers

Most cat trees have a scratching post or two incorporated into their design.

While my cats did use the posts (a lot!), I wasn’t happy with them overall. The sisal would wear out or come unglued. Some companies offer replacement posts, but I never tried that option. Seems like a headache to disassemble the cat tree to attach the new post. But if you’re willing to do that, a cat tree scratching post might be a great option.

Here, Olive shows off her handiwork.

A cat tree we bought that I do like is the Lotus Cat Tower from The Refined Feline, which has a replaceable scratcher mat. We haven’t had to replace it yet (we bought it nearly two years ago). But when we do need to swap it out, the mat will come off easily since it’s attached by velcro. Sophie uses the scratcher mat almost every morning. I think it’s to wake me up for breakfast.

Check out The Refined Feline Lotus Cat Tower on Amazon.

Functional scratcher furniture

Another piece of furniture we bought is from the same company as the tree mentioned above. When we bought new couches, we didn’t want our cats scratching the ends, like they did with our old sofa. So, we purchased these end tables that have scratch mats on them. Our cats don’t actually use them (for scratching), but they also don’t scratch the new sofa. We will keep the end tables as a deterrent. And who knows, maybe one day they will use them. (It’s the same scratch mat as the tree that gets used daily, so I know it’s not a matter of not liking the material.)

You can check out these end tables on Amazon.

Cat shelves with scratchers

Another thing to consider is installing cat shelves in your house. And if you do, you can mount ones that have scratching posts or mats. Here are two that we purchased to install in our cat room.

This first one is a cat shelf by Fukumaru.

And here’s another offering by Fukumaru, but it’s a cat tree mounted on the wall.

And finally, here is a scratching post on the wall of my office. These scratching posts are from Catastrophic Creations. You can get them as part of their predesigned Crossroads Wall Cat Scratcher set.

We received these wall shelves pictured above for free when we partnered with Catastrophic Creations to write about 5 Reasons to Install Cat Shelves for Your Cat’s Happiness. Note that we already had purchased our own set of shelves from Catastrophic Creations, and we partnered with them because we like them so much! Read about setting up our cat walls in our cat room.

Cat scratcher mat

One last option to consider buying is a big ol’ scratch mat. We’ve never tried one, as I don’t have a place to put it, but I thought they’re worth mentioning. Some people also attach a carpet scratcher or scratch mats to their walls, to allow for vertical scratching. That’s something I may try in the future with one of these days. Check out this cat scratcher mat on Amazon.

So, which one do you think is the best scratcher option for your cat? Which type(s) do you already use? Are there any that you don’t like? Let me know in the comments!

Check out the list we compiled of cat scratchers on Amazon.

Instagram | About Us